Views from a Mayo Clinic School of Medicine Student

Prior to starting the clinical portion of my training, I often wondered what it would be like to be the provider for a patient who is not able to manage their disease as advised. My goal was to have an approach to the patient that was not paternalistic, but I find this to be easier said than done. Mainly, the difficulty arises from the role placed automatically upon the physician, whose counsel is sought by patients because that physician is perceived to be an expert in his or her field. It’s a challenge to rise to this role, to speak confidently (as we are taught to do early on in third year), and yet to balance this with humility — the quality that patients actually need.

Recently, I was expected to discuss a patient’s case with a team, in front of the patient, in the patient’s hospital room. I was to have a plan and sound “confident and unwavering.” But, honestly, I struggled — because there is so much at this stage, and will be at every stage of my career, that I do not and cannot know. Even if I was already the world’s expert on a limited subset of disease in one specialty, I still would not know the details of this patient’s life, the detail that will cause this patient to not be able to adhere to a plan, unless I begin a conversation with them from the standpoint that only they can teach me about themselves. I can be truly confident of what I know if I humbly gather that information and tailor disease-related advMontenegroice to the patient’s context.

Ms. Montenegro is a third-year Mayo Clinic School of Medicine student, writing as part of her family medicine clerkship.

Advertisements

One thought on “Views from a Mayo Clinic School of Medicine Student

  1. Very thoughtful. The best physicians I have encountered who are truly healers, have been confident in the knowledge that it is not possible to know everything, that evidence, not anecdote rules the day, although gut feelings of both patient and doctor count, that each patient is an individual, that each case teaches the physician something, and that one’s education is never over.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s